Sedition and Pockets wrote:
Dembo wrote:
EldritchSun wrote:
US has no real left and it's not like you need Communism or fully loaded Socialism to be a better country. Look at Scandinavia. They care about the people and the Government's efforts are mostly directed at improving life standards first and profits following than the opposite. They understand that providing a better lifestyle to the general population and managing resources efficiently in the short term means to have steady profits and savings in the long run. Look at healthcare. If US would put some real effort on providing a quality and extended healthcare of everybody, the country's health WILL improve significantly, which will mean massive savings in the health system later.
The myth of Scandinavian socialism is tiresome. Every "right" the workers have gotten has been due to the "threat" of revolutionary socialists (communists), which is why since the collapse of the Soviet Union, those "rights" are being dismantled one by one. Hospitals, retirement homes, schools, etc. are being privatized and run for the sake of individual profit, the right to strike is being countered, etc.
And all of this involves social democrats to a high degree, because they are and always have been the left wing alibi of bourgeois pseudo-democracy.
I cannot emphasize enough that any "gains" working and oppressed people obtain under capitalism are always subject to revision, circumscription, and outright revocation.
What the ruling class gives with one hand, it can always take away with the other. We can see this with almost every victory obtained over last century. Labor rights have been all but extinguished, and unions are a shadow of a ghost of what they once were. The women's movement has spent the 50 years since
Roe fighting desperately just to hold on to the last vestiges of the right to abortion, to the exclusion of almost every other struggle for the rights of women. The ACA is being eroded one piece at a time, and we're watching the catastrophic failure of the American healthcare system unfold in real time. At this point, it is a near certainty that 500,000-1,000,000 Americans will perish before the COVID crisis is contained. The Civil Rights and Voting Rights acts have been virtually eviscertaed; meaningful progress towards racial equality stalled decades ago. A mere five years after
Obergfell came down, the Supreme Court stands poised to kick the guts out of it and return queer folks to the status of second-class citizens in their own marriages.
Nothing we gain under capitalism can last so long as capitalism remains the governing system of the world. We have only one choice. We must
smash the capitalist system. We must
shatter the capitalist state and
obliterate the class of thieves it represents. Only then can we build a new world—a better world—from the ashes of the old.
You people make holding my tongue very,
very difficult, even if I decided a good while ago that I would not participate in politics discussion here. But sure, let's have a go at this...
First of all, if you really think communism is the solution to such things as the problems of LGBTQ people or abortion rights, you must have your facts and priorities checked. There is NO historical basis for claiming that sexual minorities were ever really treated any better in communist/socialist countries than elsewhere to my knowledge. It is not a problem of capitalism, no matter how you look at it, but a result of people fearing what they do not understand, and people in power using that for creating division and making up strawman enemies. Saying socialism in any of its forms is a solution to those issues is a daydream and bullshit, it is NOT a product of a economical model in a country. The last I heard, states in the USA still had gender neutral marriage laws, and if that is not an example of progressive sexual freedom in the most ultra-capitalist country in the world, I don't know what would be. Yes, people have their opinions, biases and bigotries, but it's quite obvious that pretty much everywhere in the western world, excluding East European banana republics and places with the highest banjos-to-people ratios, there has been steady and true progress in the past 50 years.
And if you think simply enough to equate abortion rights to freedom, I guess you could say the USSR was a paradise: they actually had a decade or three with more abortions than live births, so if you use that as a metric, it must have been blissful. I'd sure prefer a place where contraceptives are available, kids get good and honest sex education, abortion is available if necessary, and it also has alternatives such as guilt-free adoption options and such. Socialism did not have those, and I have no reason to believe it would, either, seeing how population growth has always been one of the basic ways to promote extreme ideologies.
Both of those rights would be equally much subject to reversion under any socialist or communist regimes as under the capitalist system. They have little relation to the economical models in place.
And when it comes to Scandinavia, please try to make some sense. The workers' rights in Finland, for example, were built first under the damn Russian empire, then between our stupid civil war and the Winter War (1918-1939), starting from VERY right wing capitalist rule. The Reds lost the civil war, and in most places with a capitalist rule, they would have been crushed and the country could well have been the most right-wing place in Europe. Insetad, in just 21 years, the rules were changed so drastically that with the exception of a very tiny minority of extreme leftists, the nation fought as one man against the "liberators" who were about to provide the oppressed masses with the sweet socialism they were supposed to crave. The people actually sat down, had a chat, and
agreed on things, and the losers in the civil war also got to say stuff. That's how you build functional societies, not by rising up in arms. Yes, it was a product of the civil war, or rather its aftermath, to a large extent, and the need for national healing was a major driver in the process of change, but it was not anything close to the revolution you depict.
And when it comes to the current erosion of workers' rights and whatnot, I personally blame the left more than the right. While the right is always willing to grab more, it's still quite modest in its stated goals, and we have more liberties and benefits from the state than we ever had in the 1970's and other times with a more hard line left. However, the left here has lost its bearings, and has utterly failed to adapt to the changing times. The recent prime minister, social democrat Antti Rinne, is a prime example of a person who, despite being less than a decade older than I am, still thinks he lives in the shadow of the smokestacks of factories and fights in the forefront of the united workers' unions. It's bullshit. There are virtually no classes here any more, and I know electricians with stock portfolios, and guys working in paper mills who make more money than I do as a development manager with my Master's degree in a telecoms company. Yes, there are differences in incomes, but you need to go in the opposite extremes to find a multiplier higher than four between the wages of people, and that is a very good thing for the people. It still gives healthy incentive to get education and working, but does not result in excesses like in the US. We have social mobility, and people such as myself, with working class backgrounds, can pretty easily get university education without wending up to our necks in debt. My family, from both sides, has gone from very small scale farmers and laborers to university educated majority among my cousins in just two generations, and that is all due to our combo of social democracy and capitalism, most of the time under the looming shadow of the USSR.
Yes, we might be rolling back some workers' rights and benefits the state cannot pay for. But the world is changing, and it's easy to see that in our (or rather, you youngsters'...) lifetimes we will see a situation where some sort of universal income model is absolutely vital, because the increases in productivity are still taking huge leaps, and without some sort of change in the ways the benefits are reaped, there will be sizable part of the population with very few means of supporting themselves.
I'm quite probably among the top 2% of this site's user base when it comes to paying taxes, knowing our heavy taxation and my relatively comfortable income levels. But I also believe I'm among the 2% happiest tax payers, because I get things for my money. My kids have gone to good schools for free, I get healthcare when I need it, my parents are doing OK despite their illnesses, and I feel very safe here. I'd rather pay taxes to keep everybody alive, well, equal, and as happy as possible, than hand the same money over to healthcare insurance companies willing to fuck me if I ever get sick, to schools where I'd have to work hard to get my kids into, or guards of a gated community. Believe or not, no matter how much you downplay the Scandinavian success from both the right and the left, people are surprisingly happy here, and don't even complain about the taxes too much. A society can work without being either super capitalist or a full-blown socialist dystopia.
The greatest one-sentence life lesson I've ever gotten was, incidentally, from an openly communistic construction work mate, 20 years my senior. I was about 22, and he listened to us arguing about death penalty on a coffee break. Being young, we were very confident about our opinions, and he was a bit amused, I guess. His comment?
"I still remember being young enough to know all the correct answers myself, too."
That has stuck with me for over a quarter of a century now. The older I get, the more I think I understand the shades between black and white, and the more I try to understand the motivations behind different people's weird opinions and ideas. It is good to try to take a look behind the facade sometimes, even if what you see is repulsive at first sight.
And no, communism is NOT the solution, any more than the most bulldozing variants of capitalism are.