Has anyone here bought CDs from these guys before? I got the debut album from Coexistence and the CD will not play in my car, and I know it's not my car because all of my other CDs play perfectly fine. I even contacted the label about the issue and they sent me another copy of the album, and this one won't play either.

Not bought from your source but I do have access to several cd players in the house and in my cars. Yes I do have the odd cd that just wont play in a certain player. Just one of the those things. Nothing to worry about and probably not the the manufacturers fault. Hope this helps.

Bought here, no problem with them/their stuff on house CD players (just shipping who takes time, but it's normal with distance).
But i've not tried in car, as previous message says maybe the player is not compatible?
You should solve the problem with making a CD-R of this album.