Here is the list:
http://www.metal-archives.com/board/vie ... hp?t=28789

You are wrong on your line of though on this matter. If a band is rejected the moderators of the site do not add it to this list. The list is for band which are ENTIRELY rejected frmo the site and will never be accepted or a lot of evidence is needed to change the owners site on the matter of this band; like Slipknot for instance or Soulfly.

If you made a submission and it was rejected, you will receive an E-mail with an explanation why it was rejected and what additional information would be necessary to get this band accepted here. If, what happens now and then, you actually did not recieve an E-mail please use THISthread to ask about the band; please pass the post some information on the band links and the sort.

Thank you.

edit: and stay friendly and calm... and do not overreact because your submission had been rejected.

edit2: There is a good deal of punk in it.. I think too much if the samples are representative on the MySpace site:
http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fu ... D=58481732
the 2003 has more metal in it than the previous ones...

Hi metallers, I have a lillte dilemma......
Yesterday I submited a band called Saul Blanch, that released 2 albums in the early 90's under "Saul Blanch" name. But in 2006 he released an album under the name "Saul Blanch Revancha".
Then my question is, should I submit another band called "Saul Blanch Revancha"? or just add the new release, the new line-up, etc. in the current "SB" band?
I'm a bit confused because we have, for example Yngwie Malmsteen, and Yngwie Malmsteen's Rising Force in the same entry, but in the other hand we have the Paul Di'anno's case...
Sorry if its a bad question.... I haven't found a rule about that...
Thanks

Hey would a youtube video be enough to prove a band is metal?
Actually, is it metal? They have a rather large discography, and i don't want to work a lot just to get them rejected.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Phb14q_5 ... re=related
Thanks.

destruccion: that's a good question. I guess it depends on whether the artist sees it as continuation of the former name, or as a brand new project. In this case you can submit a new band, just make sure their album is also metal.
By the way, I take you're a V8 fan?

dust666: technically it's not enough proof, since it doesn't prove that the whole album is metal. You'd have to back it up with further evidence, such as reviews.

I'll see what i can find, thanks .

For Funeral Shadow, I do own the last Verbal Abuse album and the music on it is pretty much pure thrash, so stop with that crossover thing. If there is some hc influence left, then very minimal only.

For all - report band genres only whe they are completely wrong, not when you think this band is brutal enough to have it also in the genre etc.

http://www.societysfinest.com/

This is Tim Lambesis of As I Lay Dying fame's former band. First I'm wondering if the band has been previously rejected. Secondly the material on their page is from their newest record without Tim and is commercial metalcore, at least in my opinion. Anyways I'm wondering if it is metal enough to get them accepted. If not I have their second album before Lambesis departure and it is substantially heavier and more Death Metal based. So if need be i can post it for review. Opinions?

Thanks

Do not know, if it was previously rejected, quite possible, if yes, hardly anybody will remember.
The material on myspace really is quite far from being consequently metal, it has only some metal riffs here and there.

Thanks MMisantropo, well, i have found an article/interview, that begins "Saul Blanch returns to the scenes with a new band called: Saul Blanch Revancha..." So it seems to be something new, .....About the genre, well, i think it's heavy metal with some hard rock influences, anyways i will attach a download link for evaluation.
And I'm a V8 fan, i love south american metal

Yes I was certain that the newest album wasn't metal, but I thought I'd ask anyways before taking the time to upload their other record.

I'll post up their second album for review then. Thanks Witcher.

Reports for Murw


December 3rd, 2007
Posted at 18:50

It is impossible to change the track's lenghts or add a picture!
please fix this
Metalhead - [give 1 pts] - [delete] Klaagzang

Dear Klaagzang, if you would use your eyes a bit, you would see three links to diverse guidelines on the main page, where you would learn, that only VETERANS can update existing stuff. So all is wanted, desired and no exceptions are allowed.

http://www.divshare.com/download/2988980-dec

Here's the link to the second album by Society's Finest. If this isn't metal enough by the M-A standards then the band has no other chance. The album is basically Death/Metalcore with some elements of Groove.

Oh also, Tim Pidun of Atisha http://www.metal-archives.com/band.php?id=94554 and Unknown Species
http://www.metal-archives.com/band.php?id=103523 has asked me to add his previous band Gangmen to the archives, he says that they played Traditional Heavy Metal (ala Dio, Rage & Saxon) and gave me more then enough info to make a very complete submission, my question is do I need some sort of outside source to prove that they are traditional metal, as I do not have any samples, or would his word be enough (I can send the email to a mod for validation). If not I can request a track from the gangmen releases but apparently the band has been defunct for quite awhile so I do not know if he still has their material.

Today I have seen everything, somebody submitted Brown Attack, a NS rac/oi! band from Malaysia (!!!)
.

Influences . Skrewdriver among others:



http://www.myspace.com/bstbrownattack

To all:Stop adding the Alestorm album to Battleheart page.

When it comes out, a new Alestorm page would be set up. Not sooner!!!!

At least one Gangmen song would be useful, he is most probably sincere, but just to be sure.

http://www.divshare.com/download/3002196-317

Here's two tracks from Gangmen's last demo. Thanks for your time Witcher.

Good German power metal, submit immediately.

Submitted, he forgot to give me the last known line-up, so I've sent him another message, I'll add it as soon as he replies.

Reports for Cross Denied


December 4th, 2007
Posted at 22:58

Apostate:Vox
S.K.:6 Strings & Elimination Of christ's Propaganda
Akhkhar:5 Strings & Elimination Of christ's Propaganda
Maelstrom : Artillery
Ayloss:6 Strings (live member)

-Snegodron(ex- Enshadowed):session vox at live with Mayhem


-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Just perfect.. and stuff like that gets reported every day...

You have been told to submit them and that we will see then.

My updates on Dave Lombardo:

I asked him about the band Philm via MySpace and got this reply. Several pages were changed. I thought it would be good to mention it here, as there is hardly any information on the matter available on the net.

edit: Should the matter of Philm be mentioned/explained on the Kkleq Muzzil page or elsewhere or not at all?

http://www.aeonspoke.com/ Non metal music,but it's project of Paul Masvidal and Sean Reinert.Opinions?

A side-project with worldwide distribution under SPV. The music really isn't a factor.

It was formed when Cynic wasn't active. I think Aeon Spoke is more of a main project for those guys, in any case.

Paul is a member of Gordian Knot, who still can be considered metal. Aeon Spoke were started during that band's period of existence. What is and what is not a main band could be discussed for ages, that is why I am for further limitation of the side project rule.

Hi

Is this nu-metal?

http://www.purevolume.com/t.o.d.metal

Side-project of Heirdrain:
http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fu ... =164948097
(yes it is a pathetic as the main band)

Ambient with some small BM parts
http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fu ... =112344397
release is out.

I just want to ask, if this band should be added according to the side-project rule.

No label with a world distribution, so no. Already on the rejected list.

37 Stabwoundz .This band is on rejected list,but to me they sounds like Groove Metal (MACHINE HEAD,CROWBAR influences) with HardCore vocals and some Riffs.Maybe a too modern,but... As far as I understood this hand have HardCore background.

Sorry,but do not found more samples.

Too close to nu-metal for me and on the rejected list from the start, so you would have to convince Morrigan first - not too probable in this case.

nope.

http://www.myspace.com/quevivanlosmuertos On Rejected list???? This is really strange.Maybe because that in this project plays guys from STATIC-X or BODY COUNT.But the music without doubts FITS here.

http://www.metalunderground.com/reviews ... easeid=359

Yes, you are right, this is some kind of thrash/death with only slight groove elements at times.

No reason given on the rejcted list, so removed.

Hi

This release http://www.tollbooth.org/review99/cotgrave.html features 5 bands , 4 are regitered but the 5th is not .

Is this enough to be accepted?

Yes, it is enough to read the rules on adding albums in this case.

I know the rule for the splits , but i thought , 1 track!? . but anyway if i submit it , can the release be deleted in the other bands so it can added properly?

Submit it first.

ok

Shouldn't this be another entry at the MA?
http://www.metal-archives.com/release.php?id=30135

It was released as Steppenwolf; I have the tape in front of me.
After this release they changed their name to Megalith